26.08.2013
What kind of self-regulating organisation do we need?
The need for self-regulation is becoming ever more apparent. The most advanced discussions are already taking the form of initiatives to draft a law on self-regulating organisations (SROs). Without going into the various forms of the wishes and interests of those taking part in the discussions, it can be said with certainty that what is at stake is the expression of group interests. Often these interests coincide across groups from entirely different sectors.
It is therefore quite clear that we need SROs. But what kind? Moreover, self-regulation begins already at the stage of discussing whether the draft law needs to be adopted at all. In other words, the quality of the law will depend on which group’s arguments prevail. Since there are plenty of views, opinions and examples from other countries, it is reasonable to tie all the details back to the fundamental principles of self-regulation.
The basic function of an SRO
Self-regulation as a basic function is, after all, regulation within a group of associated entities. These are lawful formations, so their association cannot be regarded as criminal. Relations between two entities can be governed by their contractual obligations. In a group of three or more, agreements must be raised to the level of rules. Agreements apply piecemeal; rules are absolute for SRO members.
Introducing self-regulation is not about mergers or acquisitions. Consequently, even competing entities in the same sector can belong to an SRO if they accept common rules of the game. Competition is then transformed into competition between the group of SRO members and non-members. Nature offers plenty of examples of species forming packs as well as living alone. The conclusion is simple: by uniting and adopting certain rules, life can be organised quite effectively.
The same examples from nature show the effectiveness of self-organisation among bees, ants and so on. Association in an SRO is therefore not only possible but effective.
An SRO for development
No one would say that an operating business joins an SRO in order to be liquidated or destroyed afterwards. Clearly, association is driven by the desire to survive together through cooperation, division of functions and so on.
An SRO is an association for development. The key point is that associated entities develop faster than the “hermits” who have not signed up to common rules. Moreover, an SRO of associated entities can outpace the state in the speed of decision-making.
If one asks who is more interested in developing a given sector — the state or the businesses themselves — the answer is obvious. It is enterprises that are interested in their own development, and it is by their signs of development that one can judge the state of the sector. The state, even if extremely interested, has no direct levers over business in market conditions. But the state, in turn, also prefers a “fatter” taxpayer, and in such cases it pays close attention to the interests and needs of such enterprises.
It is therefore reasonable to conclude that SROs accelerate the development of a sector. Nothing remains for the state but to monitor the basic criteria of quality control of results. In essence, this means giving SROs the right to decide how the sector should develop and what future to choose. Naturally, the SRO’s members themselves bear responsibility for their choice.
Should this be seen as competition between SROs and the state? By no means. It is a division of powers in determining the future of a given sector. “Render unto Caesar”. The state grants the sector the right and the opportunity to develop faster, and in return expects greater tax revenue from a more developed level of business activity.
Dividing lines in regulation
Introducing SRO principles logically raises the question of dividing the spheres of regulation. Only the application of physical laws based on clear mathematical calculation can eliminate a subjective approach to that division. The normative method of cost accounting is more important than ever in dividing spheres of interest; it provides a common basis for substantive dialogue between the tax inspector and the entrepreneur based on physical indicators.
Signs of development are generally determined by the level of standards accepted in society, and it is the leaders of a sector that introduce them. To divide spheres of regulation, the concepts of norms and standards must be separated. Both consist of indicators showing the degree of development. Raising a standard is nothing other than a cyclical raising of those indicators.
The division of roles therefore consists in the state monitoring basic norms while SROs take care of raising sectoral standards. This can logically be extended to other spheres. If the state provides social infrastructure in the form of general education based on current basic knowledge applied in practice, then raising standards requires the whole sector to concentrate on innovative, advanced scientific solutions that deliver a breakthrough. Likewise, fundamental research remains with the state, while business gives it an applied character through paid commissions or contract research.
Financing development
No one objects to development if it means a better future. In relations between SROs and the state it is important to agree not only on the points of regulation but also on the cost that will fall on each side.
Indicators of norms and standards come down to the quality of the technologies and equipment used. It is indisputable that more advanced modern equipment gives better results. The question of financing development therefore comes down to dividing the sources. At whose expense should business develop? How can an entrepreneur replace equipment in order to supply consumers with higher-quality products competitive with world standards? In what form will the state provide that opportunity? What part of income can be attributed to cost and what part to results — in other words, what will the consumer pay for and what will the entrepreneur pay for?
To answer this, another question must first be settled: is it worth changing the current practice in which the entrepreneur pays for everything? This should be considered from a social point of view. Socially, developing a sector means above all creating jobs. Jobs are created where innovation is introduced. Jobs are also eliminated there, raising labour productivity by replacing human labour with machinery.
Neither the state nor society will object to improving the quality and quantity of jobs. Here we get a clear answer, and behind it lies the answer to another question: at whose expense development should take place and how the benefits of selling more competitive, higher-quality products should be shared.
This question, like all the others in the chain “SRO – development – innovation – taxes”, must become the subject of dialogue between business and the state. The SRO, as the sector’s representative, must become the direct vehicle for expressing the sector’s consolidated interests. Only through such dialogue can the principles of relations be established in real practice.
Refusing to cooperate
The final question in considering how to advance the SRO idea is the refusal of the state or of the potential SROs themselves to engage in dialogue — either separately or jointly rejecting the principles of self-regulation altogether.
Consider first a joint refusal by both the state and business groups. This should be seen as a rejection of the principles of organised, more effective sectoral development.
Consumers have a right to better products and better service, and they have a right to choose. If neither the state nor entrepreneurs make any effort to secure their place in the sun, buyers will decide in favour of foreign goods.
The main criterion of development in the survival of companies and countries is competitiveness. At the current stage of globalisation, the more competitive country is the one with more competitive laws and regulations — and those are developed taking into account the interests of the market players themselves.
Hardly anyone doubts that the lion’s share of state funding comes from taxes paid by local business, which is scarcely comparable with external donor inflows. Business not only supports the state but also serves as the source for repaying external borrowing. It therefore has every right to “order” the rules of the game it needs for a breakthrough in a competitive environment.
The state may refuse, but at the expense of growth in the number and size of individual taxpayers. Which official needs convincing that more tax can be collected from a billionaire than from a millionaire? Caring for one’s own “goose that lays the golden eggs” is therefore an entirely rational decision.
As for business refusing to create SROs, this option need not even be considered. No entrepreneur starts a business in order to be destroyed by competitors afterwards — whether those competitors are domestic or foreign.
Abai Alymkulov, economist
Source: skicluster.kg